- Dagor Agraleb - Decision 2002 (Vote thread)
- Judging - King Elessar's choice
- Gandalf's Road: Judgement Day
- Judgment - Round 1: Scholars vs. Periaur
- Judgment - Round 1: Outcasts vs. Tolkienology
- Judgment - Round 1: OiE vs. Elves/Dwarves
- Judgment - Round 2: Scholars vs OiE
- Judgment - Round Two: Elves/Dwarves vs. Outcasts
- Judgment - Round 2: Tolkienology vs. Periaur
- Judgment--Round 3: Periaur vs Elves/Dwarves.
- Judging: Round 3 Scholar's Hall vs. Tolkienology
- Judgement - Round 3: Outcasts vs OiE
- Judging round 4-Outcasts vs. Periaurs
- Round 4: Judgement Tolkienologist vs OiE
- Fourth Round Judging Thread For The Dwarf And elf And Scholar Types!
- Round 5 debate : outcast vs Scholars
- Judgement - Round 5: Tolkienology vs. Elves/Dwarves
- Judging, Round 5: OiE vs GoP
- Round 6, Guild of Outcasts vs. Guild of Tolkienologists
- Judgement for Round 6: GoE vs. OiE
- Debate Tournament - Round 6: Guild of the Periaur vs. Guild of Scholar's Hall
- Round 7, Guild of Outcasts vs. Guild of Elves and Dwarves
- Round 7 Guild of Periaur vs. Guild of Tolkienology
- Round 7:GoS vs.GoiE
- Social Debate: Who is Hotter? Fingon or Finduilas? [Judging]
- Round 8: Tolkienology vs. Scholars
- Judging, Round 8 - GoE vs GoP
- Judgement - Round 8: Ost-in-Edhil vs. Guild of Outcasts
- Judging: Round 9 Ost-in-Edhil vs. Tolkienology
- Judgment, Round 9: Guild of Outcasts vs. Guild of the Periaur
- Judgement, Round 9: The Guild of Scholars v The Guild of Eruhini
- Judging: Snaga... oops I mean Periaur ;) vs. OiE
- Judging: GoE Vs GoT round 10
- Judging Round 10-GoS vs. GoO