PDA

View Full Version : Tolkien's versus Jackson's 'LOTR'


Pages : 1 [2]

  1. Grinding Prime Rib into Hamburger Meat
  2. The Motivation that Maneuvers the Malevolent Meat Masher
  3. Crickhollow to Barrow Downs in the films
  4. Hobbit Movie?
  5. Direct Quotes
  6. An epic secret is out
  7. where is the rest of the book?
  8. Questions that need answering
  9. The worst of the three movies
  10. A sign of the times?
  11. Should they make a remake?
  12. Alot less Fans
  13. Purists: I now understand!
  14. What has become of us?
  15. What Tolkien himself would have thought...
  16. Tolkien in the movies?
  17. Purity and the Critics
  18. Purists Unite!
  19. A new site very good
  20. Have you listened to the BBC Radio Play?
  21. A purist's recap: What could have been better?
  22. If you could add a scene(s) to the LOTR
  23. If you could add a scene to the LOTR or take out a scene would?
  24. The eye of Sauron
  25. Mordor, She Wrote.
  26. Tobey Maguire as Frodo?
  27. What have you people got against PJ?
  28. Scholarly Review of Tolkien versus Jackson
  29. A Nit-Pickers Guide to Deviations Between the Books and the Films
  30. Hats off to Jackson. Way better than JRRT!
  31. I have just noticed something
  32. Newsweek's series of articles about PJ's LOTR
  33. Frodo and Sam's physicality
  34. Closest Characterisations
  35. The Shore/Lennox/Jackson musical collaboration
  36. The Concept of Kingship
  37. Quality of Acting
  38. Rate the characterizations of scenes/places
  39. Quendi and... not Eldar!?!?
  40. Thread for movie "misquotes"
  41. Language in the films
  42. A professional's views on film humo(u)r
  43. Books, films, art, cash, and Tolkien
  44. Will young people pick up Tolkien, or simply say, "Yeah, I saw it, it was OK"??
  45. To Mordor and Back
  46. The 'Rings' trilogy thunders to a royally fine conclusion
  47. LOTR Costumery, Etc.
  48. A Clean Sweep!
  49. For Peter Jackson fans only!
  50. And Frodo makes five (Part One)
  51. LOTR hits the small screen in November!
  52. Continuity Errors
  53. Can Other Tolkien Stories Be Made Into Movies?
  54. Boramir v Faramir whos better?
  55. A Scene I Wish They had In The Movie...
  56. strange coincidences between film and cartoon.
  57. Gandalf in FotR
  58. The Lord of the Rings Symphony at the Hollywood Bowl
  59. In the movies it bothered me that Frodo was so naive...
  60. Alternate Directors
  61. What Tolkien May Have Thought...
  62. So we can all pack up this site and go home???
  63. War in the movie fora
  64. A report on a lecture by Tom Shippey
  65. Why is Jackson better than Baskhi?
  66. This has been "bugging" me
  67. Snowy Bill
  68. Jackson interview
  69. Battle at Helms Deep
  70. Did the actors hit their peak?
  71. Forum Title and Characterisation Comparisons
  72. What PJ changes upset you?
  73. The best sound track out off them all...
  74. Gollum's into Monkey Business!
  75. Music similar to the LOTR soundtrack?
  76. Tolkien wasn't Irish...
  77. Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11 will beat PJ's LOTR Box Office record !!!!!
  78. wait just a minute what if tolkien got it wrong
  79. Supa Dupa new Figurine in the 10 VOL LOTR EE SET
  80. extended/directors cut trilogy set?!?
  81. Peter Jackson vs Blizzard Games Cinematics
  82. Silmarillion, the Movie: Locations
  83. John Boorman's 70s script
  84. so...
  85. The Lord of the Rings Symphony
  86. Peter Jackson in Perspective - a new book
  87. LOTR in HD DVD
  88. Jackson and Bakshi vs. Tolkien
  89. Magic Moments
  90. Anyone else seen this?
  91. The Billy Boyd Thread
  92. The case of the missing Glorfindel - PJ vs. Bakshi
  93. The LOTR Marathon Thread
  94. Le Guin or Tolkien, who got the worst of it?
  95. The Peter Jackson Thread
  96. WOW - Blizzard North's OST trumphs Howard shore's OST
  97. The Gollum Thread
  98. How many of the LOTR reviewers are looking for invites to the next premieres???
  99. The Technogeek Thread
  100. The Lord of the Rings Motion Picture Trilogy Exhibition
  101. A movie to tell a tale and make you cry? technologically stunning masterpiece
  102. Sting Inscription
  103. Worst of the III
  104. Ringing in a Liberal or Conservative LOTR
  105. The Technomagic Thread
  106. Characterization in the movies- Aragorn
  107. The Peter Jackson LOTR parody thread
  108. Apart from Bombadil and the Scouring....?
  109. Sean Aston on Peter Jackson and LOTR experience
  110. Quotes from the IMDB from International viewers from different background, views and
  111. Why do people so desperately want Tolkienism to be good???
  112. How ironic that the major theme of Tolkienism is turned upside down by PJ
  113. The eye of Sauron
  114. Aragorn & Boromir, book vs. film
  115. General Discussion of the Jackson Trilogy
  116. LOTR-ize Your Bank Checks!!!
  117. Germans have redeemed themselves
  118. Are the Films Superior to the Books in Any Way?
  119. Lines in the movie said by other characters in the book
  120. Will there be a LOTR remake in our lifetime?
  121. Do any of you remember this part?
  122. How long before you begin to pick it apart. . Movie AND Books
  123. Book vs Movies which is better
  124. Popularity of films, if not for the book?
  125. Peter Jackson has effectively raped and destroyed my childhood
  126. How many different versions of LotR have you experienced?
  127. Artistic merits of LOTR
  128. Questions about "Aruman", Moria and the Ringwraiths.
  129. LotR Trivia List
  130. Haldir at Helm's Deep?
  131. Do films of famous works help or harm their sources?
  132. Jackson sues New Line
  133. Another Script
  134. Old Lord of the Rings
  135. The Scourging of the Shire
  136. Continuity and Inconsistencies: a general discussion
  137. The Lord of the Rings MUSICAL!
  138. PJ And Film Haters Only, Please
  139. A Mistake of Date
  140. Tolkien themes Jackson failed to grasp
  141. Strangeness on Orthanc
  142. Million dollar baby vs ROTK
  143. Lord of the Rings: the TV series
  144. Interview with the writer of the 1993 treatment of LOTR
  145. Maybe this is the best of epic film making???
  146. Stanley Kubrick's Lord of the Rings
  147. I dont really like Tolkien But................
  148. How do you picture Middle Earth
  149. OMG new version of LOTR
  150. pj planned sauron at the final battle, up untill the end!
  151. Fall and rebirth in the movies
  152. Best way to cover ME's History in Film Form
  153. Zimmerman Screenplay
  154. LOTR or Titanic?
  155. Smeagol/Gollum identity crisis
  156. How about a TV series?
  157. Jackson v Tolkien: Would Tolkien have written that?
  158. Movie question
  159. Escape of the Swanboat
  160. Major Changes from the Book to the Film