- The movie and the book
- Both the book AND the movie are GREAT
- Two points about the movie and book
- Question
- Landscape
- SUSPENSE in The Lotr
- Frodo's Bravery
- The Bridge of Khazad-dûm
- Mistakes
- Movie leaves out or changes loads of the book.
- Should they have given Arwen the extra scene?
- Part of the movie that I felt was better than the book....
- discrepancies bet. movie & book
- Was Gandalf really that tall?
- My Views on TLOTR!!
- An idea.
- Gandalf's diminished awareness
- Flight to the Ford
- Movie's success= New readers? Or no?
- Differences...
- Which Versions Better?(Flight to the Ford)
- The role of women???
- Will there be any evil men?
- SWORD that was BROKEN???
- Was It a Cave Troll or was it the Balrog?
- what would you put in/take out
- what do you think?
- Ive seen it 8 times
- I Wonder What would happen
- They have it mixed up.
- Parallels between the animated verision and PJ' s
- Movie
- why on middle earth does arwen come to them when frodo has been stabed
- What about Boromir?
- Frodo is 50... not 20...
- If you were Peter Jackson...
- Gil-Galad in the movie LOTR
- Who thinks PJ got a little carried away?
- For What It's Worth...
- Question about putting Glorfindel in the LOTR movie.
- Athelas in the movie
- Congradulations to Thorin ...
- Humorous LotR trailer at Modern Humorist
- Help me rank these adaptions of Tolkiens works...
- Where is Tom Bombadil?
- isn't it interesting?
- saruman and sauron alliance ????
- The changes webcite
- Boromir's Death
- What Would You Put In?
- "It's a story of genocide"
- Six movies better than 3?
- Orcs or vampires?
- The Prancing Pony?
- A book of journey and a film of action!!!
- The Uruk Hai
- Were Merry and Pippin clown?
- The Role of Images
- You're all bitter
- Two questions in Moria
- what do u like betta?
- Book or Movie 1st
- Galadriel Good or Bad???
- The Statues of the Kings
- The Evenstar
- Book Arwen Movie Arwen
- Differences in TTT
- Eowyn - Miranda Otto
- Why seeing Bakshi makes me love PJ
- Would you read a novelization of the LOTR Movies?
- Reading the book after seeing the movie.
- What Do You Think About Faramir?
- What's wrong with Celeborn?
- Did the film ruin your image of ME?
- LotR Or LotR movie
- The One-dimensional, One-Expressioned Characters in PJ's LOTR
- PJ's Galadriel: a hagging, nagging witch???
- blink and you'll miss it
- If PJ made the Hobbit into a film.
- PJ's LOTR
- Two Films in One: a Theory
- which scene seemed better?
- COmparing PJ's with Bakshi
- The "Vision" Thing
- Really ask yourself now...
- I have an article...
- Now I'm a PJ basher
- TTT vs. TTT movie
- The Anti - Peter Jackson Association
- PJ's Arwen more like Tolkien's Luthien?
- Who is the Fairest of them all?
- Books and imagination..
- I seen the Light !! i wont ever criticise PJ again
- Silver Screen Spider-web OR
- A "serious" question regarding EE
- Fantasy is best left to words...
- Anyone doing the Aussie Quest????
- Ideas for an animated Silmarillion
- Scenes that ought not to be omitted/ruined...
- A Better Script
- just wondering....
- Which was the part that PJ changed the most?(what you think)
- Who doesn't like Legolas?
- Did Jackson Misinterpret the Story?
- Character Discussion: Boromir
- "Meet the Feebles" vs "LOTR"
- I have a mathmatical question
- The Annotated Transcripts
- The "real" reason for the changes!!
- Just based on the preview...
- Means to the ends.
- For Mrs. Maggot - Changing the meaning etc.
- PJ's LotR: Tedious and Overwrought
- How does Jackson's LOTR fare as a book?
- The Directors Commentary
- Movie grossings are a load of *****
- How true is PJ to the book?
- Peter Jackson is a disgrace
- Gimli's Bow
- Is it art?
- in favor of PJs interpretation of faramir aka alternative adaptation
- Another Complaint about PJ...
- Which Film was the Best?
- Replacement Director?
- hey hey hey!
- Dynamics of the movie forum
- Tolkien's inconsistencies
- THE BLACK TONGUE AS SPOKEN BY GANDALF AT CoE
- LotR movie starring Humphrey Bogart
- A couple of beefs with TTT
- Jackson's "younger" Frodo
- PJ and Lord of the rings....
- PJ and Tolkien
- The Hobbit
- heather
- Peter Jackson lives with his mother!
- Areas where FOTR beats TTT...
- Praise for FOTR, TTT movies......
- Changes to the story in TTT
- Hiya pleez read
- Adaptation of LOTR? Who would be best?
- Moral and Ethical comparison
- Let's make a film
- Can i ask y'all
- I need y'alls help
- Whats your opinion?
- Best resource for ME knowledge...
- Showing your colours
- Aragorn Conflict
- Movie merchandise (sp?)
- Fav character from the movie and from the book
- Narsil
- Helms Deep
- Why Make Faramir Bad?
- Comic Relief
- Jackson and Bakshi
- When you read the books...
- Everybody Here Seen the Movies?
- What actors/actresses would you pick?
- Who...
- That's enough already.
- somebody tell me
- EVERYTHING that you did NOT like
- How did u like it?
- Another parody!
- Everything you DID like......
- YOUR adaptation
- Fav. place in Middle earth
- Question!!
- Backshi vs. jackson
- Bakshi vs. Jackson
- 'Purists' - are you going to RotK?
- Would You If You Could
- PJ and all his glory.
- lolz
- Ten Reasons Why The Movies are Better Than the Book.
- No Scouring of The Shire? + Intro
- 'Yucky' Humor
- It is said that in The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings that......
- "I know. By rights, we shouldn't even be here."
- A new perspective (possibly) on TTT changes.
- For everyone who doesn't think the movies are awful!
- Let's just accept the movie
- PJ sold out "Lord of the Rings"!
- "Thank you, J.R.R.T."?????
- the 'vs' issue
- An Issue of Storytelling
- Have the films influenced the way you picture the characters?
- The spirit behind the books
- LOTR movie. Do u like it or no?
- My new take on the movies!
- A different view on this discussion
- Everyone's opinion of Peter Jackson
- Brotherhood of the Wolf is the REAL "Lord of the Rings"
- Where's the picture from?(Game)
- Peter Jackson is NOT a disgrace
- Should Sauron take form in the movie ROTK?
- Unbelievable Bravery
- Eowyn, please!
- Lack of a theme
- Arwen's make-up
- Proof why LOTR-trilogy is an example of an excellent transferring from book to film
- Should they make "The Hobbit" a movie??
- Why does TTT fall short of FOTR?
- Now is the hour
- What character DID PJ do right, in your eyes?
- Elrond
- What is the greater travesty?
- Look any monkey can make a movie!!
- "Lord of the Rings is a story of fathers and sons..."
- Why PJ Will Fail in the Conclusion
- PJ defences...debunked.
- What happened - and why
- What was the point???
- Gandlaf: reduced by PJ?
- Silmarillion Cast List
- Which version was better?
- Peter Jackson...villain or hero?
- Silmarillion Movie!
- Did Pj suddenly forget what movie he was making
- Saruman in ROTK, or not!
- The nomad is curious
- PJ's Gollum: Does he Undermine Tolkien's Themes?
- RotK a disappointment -- even before it's out!
- Now is the hour: Part Deux
- What did PJ do right?
- Something I thought was interesting
- Hobbit as a movie
- Non-reader's opinions of Tolkien - and of Rowling
- Frodo
- Purist or not
- Peter Jackson Hints at the Hobbit
- Haircolor of elves and half-elves
- Is Peter Jackson a good director???
- Some of You People :rolleyes:
- Division
- The Writers
- There is a new book around exploiting the film!
- cartoon version of lotr and hobbit
- Tolkien Expert Unimpressed With Rings Trilogy Films
- If Peter Jackson didn't do the film
- a humble suggestion
- FFC REVIEW
- Popular without P.J?
- FAD's POINT PROVEN
- Popular without LOTR?
- PURISTS: 50 reasons LOTR sucks
- Wagner's Influence on Shore's LOTR Scores
- Goro's Review (Spoilers)
- Making the Movie.