Ancalagon
03-30-2003, 02:03 AM
I have been mulling this idea over in my mind for a long time (then Beorn took it to a new level) and would like your feedback.
I guess it is fairly self-explanatory, considering the title of the thread. A league, including all TTF Guilds who wish to debate against each other, in a home and away match.
A format for scoring the outcomes could be based on the number of votes each Guild gets following their debates, with an eventual winner, or even a decider.
I had also thought it would be interesting to ensure questions selected for debate must be representative of all Tolkiens major works. In addition, I had envisaged that each team could only make a maximum of 8 replies, assuming each team consists of 4 members?
It is all just thought bouncing aimlessly around my head, but I would like your thoughts on the matter.
Regards
AncalagonleBlack
I guess it is fairly self-explanatory, considering the title of the thread. A league, including all TTF Guilds who wish to debate against each other, in a home and away match.
A format for scoring the outcomes could be based on the number of votes each Guild gets following their debates, with an eventual winner, or even a decider.
I had also thought it would be interesting to ensure questions selected for debate must be representative of all Tolkiens major works. In addition, I had envisaged that each team could only make a maximum of 8 replies, assuming each team consists of 4 members?
It is all just thought bouncing aimlessly around my head, but I would like your thoughts on the matter.
Regards
AncalagonleBlack