A slight problem...

[Celebthôl]

I joined the Periaur, after I was asked to, then I was ask to join GoT, and i did, but I was told that i could only be in one guild, however i do not wish to leave either one......is there anyway around this problem so that i can remain in both guilds?

Thanx ~Thôl~

[Eriol]

WARNING: This opinion comes from a very ignorant person as regards Guild regulations.

We have people who are members of more than one Guild here. I don't suppose this is a rule of GoT. So, there are these alternatives:

1) This is an internal rule of Periaur; if so, there's nothing much we can do about it here.

2) What you heard is not accurate. I know there is an impediment for people belonging in two different Guilds as regards the Debate Tournament; and even so people are not forced to resign from one of the Guilds, rather to pick one Guild to defend in the Tournament and stick with it until the end (no team-swapping).

Keep in mind the warning at the beginning of the post; I hope I've helped :).

[Celebthôl]

That sounds fair :)

Thank you Mr Eriol. . .i was hoping that that was the case, but we'll see :)

[Eriol]

What's with the "Mr."? Now only Lhun will call me "Eri"?

:D ;)

[Celebthôl]

Alright :) Mr Eir ;) hows that? ;) :D

[Lhunithiliel]

A good chat, boys! ;) :D
Nice to see you here BOTH! :D

Thol..What Eri said is true. Only in inter-guild debating this may be a problem!

So, as far as I am concerned, you are most welcome here! :)

[Celebthôl]

:) Hehe, thank you :) thats the answer i was hoping for :)

[Lhunithiliel]

Always at your service! ;) :D

Say...Is it hard to tame a grifin? ;)

[Celebthôl]

Originally posted by Lhunithiliel
Always at your service! ;) :D

Say...Is it hard to tame a grifin? ;)

Hehe, well it isnt totally tame...but it was a challege...took me about a year :)

[Lhunithiliel]

Who's the griffin ? ;) :D

Say,.. we here have a tradition - the new applicants are invited to share all about their experience and knowledhge in Tolkien works -how much they know them and how much they are interested to learn. You can do this in the Application - thread.
Then, the next step will be to introduce yourself at the "Meet the Guild"-thread...

So... I invite you to keep the tradition! :)

[Aulë]

No, I'm pretty sure that you can only be in one Guild out of the Periaur, GoT, GoS and OiE.
It was because of this rule that I was unable to join the GoT in March.
Compare the membership lists: there is no-one (apart from Thol) who is in more than one of the four.

[Celebthôl]

Who's the griffin ? ;) :D

My girlfriend...Oren ;) its on account of her MSN address "griffin_of_destiny" hehe....shes still not to much tamed ;)

Say,.. we here have a tradition - the new applicants are invited to share all about their experience and knowledhge in Tolkien works -how much they know them and how much they are interested to learn. You can do this in the Application - thread.
Then, the next step will be to introduce yourself at the "Meet the Guild"-thread...

Ill do it when i have time next :)

So... I invite you to keep the tradition! :)

Thank yee :)

No, I'm pretty sure that you can only be in one Guild out of the Periaur, GoT, GoS and OiE.
It was because of this rule that I was unable to join the GoT in March.
Compare the membership lists: there is no-one (apart from Thol) who is in more than one of the four.

Theres always room for change ;) this could be the forefront of a reveloution :D ;)

[Lhunithiliel]

Originally posted by Aulë
No, I'm pretty sure that you can only be in one Guild out of the Periaur, GoT, GoS and OiE.
It was because of this rule that I was unable to join the GoT in March.
But Aule... Really... In March I don't think I was in charge of this Guild ....Besides, there wasn't a Debating Tournament at that time...
But How come I don't remember you wanted to join our Guild? :eek: I am sorry membership was refused to you!

Well...yes...the rules were a bit different back then...

Compare the membership lists: there is no-one (apart from Thol) who is in more than one of the four. [/B]
I know that :D
But can you keep a wild soul like Thol in the "cage" of one Guild? ;) :D

I don't know... This issue - membership in more than one guild has not been very seriously addressed yet. Maybe it should be. What does the Council of 9 have to say on the matter?

[Aulë]

The C9 has pretty much decided that it shall be the individual Guild's choice at whether they will accept members from other Guilds.

But I just found this (by accident :) ), which may be of some interest to you:
http://www.thetolkienforum.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=6011
Particularly the last paragraph of Grond's post.

[Lhunithiliel]

As I said..... Time passes and all things change... :rolleyes:

I don't have any problem with the fact the Scatha and Thol are members in more than one guild! In times of debates they shall just have to decide which guild they will stand for.