Who is your favorite in the Fellowship and why?

[Wonko The Sane]

You're trying to tell me that Orli, Elijah, Billy, and Viggo are all undernourished?

Yeah right, they're strapping specimens of male beauty.

I think Sam's just a butterball.

[tasar]

But a happy butterball!
There has to be a man for every taste in the fellowship!

[Wonko The Sane]

Ok, you got me there.

Girls that fancy that chubby, rounded type can stare at Sam.

But I've got dibs on Elijah, Orli, Viggo, um...everyone else.

[Úlairi]

LOL! I quite enjoyed that my fellow peoples.

[Wonko The Sane]

But just remember, they're MY boys!
MINE! You here!!!

*hordes hot young actors*

[tasar]

You just keep telling yourself that

[Wonko The Sane]

You're just jealous!!

*hordes hot young actors*

[tasar]

that's right, jealous and mean too.

[Wonko The Sane]

Hah! Be jealous and mean all you want!
No hot young actor boys for you!!!

*hordes hot young actor boys*

[tasar]

Oh dear. :(
Go ahead, take them ALL! See if I care!
I want men, not young actor boys.

[Frodorocks]

Frodo definetly was the best of the fellowship. He was heroic,smart,and just plain cool. Like in the end of the fellowship where he decides to leave and face doom all alone, instead of bringing his friends to death with him. Elijah Wood Rocks!!!!!

[Ellerina]

My favourite character is Merry... or Frodo! no wait Pippin oh no Sam! No no Merry oh i don't know they're all so cute!:rolleyes:

[Úlairi]

Aargh! Make up your mind.

[Wonko The Sane]

Ooh, they're plenty manly....

*drools*

[dark_angel]

i think that Legolas was the best. Orlando Bloom is such a good actor he's hot too. :D

[Úlairi]

Why has everone got such a 'thing' for Legolas?

[Legolas_lover12]

OMG! i don't think anyone has voted for frodo yet. well, that really amazes me. i like them all. gandalf is just plain cool. that bridge scene really rocked! frodo is so sweet and innocent-looking (and cute), but he can really be brave. merry is funny. and pippin is just stupid sometimes. and that makes him funny. sam is so loyal to frodo (like everyone said b4). he's really a great friend. legolas is cool. and he's soo hott. and it's funny that throughout the entire movie everyone is getting dirty and they have blood on them and everything........and then there's legolas, his hair is perfect and he doesn't have hardly any dirt or a scratch on him. i thought that was kinda funny. and aragorn is brave. he's awesome. boromir, well.............boromir is just boromir. i don't like him but i don't dislike him either. and gimli............well, i guess i don't like gimli that much, but he's there, so...........i'll get used to it. anyway my favorite person, if i really had to choose, would be frodo..............with legolas coming in at a close second. but that's mainly because i think they are hott and awesome!

[Úlairi]

Cut it out with Legolas!!!

[Theoden]

no one let me vote for Galadriel!!! Even though it looked like she stuck her finger in a toaster, she was awesome. Just like I pictured her in the book. So I voted for sam, cause he was the coolest in the book. But poor Galadriel!!!

**Weeps and gnashes his teeth because they left out an elf... the elf!**

[Legolas_lover12]

i thought galadriel was just kinda weird in the movie. that's just my opinion, though. oh, and LEGOLAS rocks! so does FRODO, ARAGORN..........:D :D :D

[Wonko The Sane]

In case you haven't been reading this thread, Frodo, Aragorn, Legolas, Merry, Pippin...etc etc etc etc are mine.
I am hoarding them.
And you can't have any.

And yes, Galadrie's scary scene was scary.

Also, Where is Legolas_Lover12 from in Indiana as I attended school there this year.

[dark_angel]

you can keep them all except for Legolas, he's mine.

[Frodorocks]

I agree with Ulairi.Why does everyone think legolas is hot??? :o He's a sissy. Orlando Bloom looks awful as a blonde. :( I voted for Frodo Legolas_lover12!!! :) He rocks!!!:) If anyone's cute, it's Frodo.

[Legolas_lover12]

wonko - i'm from seymour. where are you going to school (in indiana) and, yes again, galadriel was scary. she was just...........scary.
wonko & dark angel - NO, LEGOLAS IS MINE!!! MINE, MINE, MINE!!!:D :D :D

frodorocks - why do we think legolas is hott??!!! have u SEEN him??!!! he's gorgeous. and i think he looks awesome as a blonde!!! i like frodo too, but probably legolas more. :D :D :D :D

[tasar]

I know I saw Legolas and...should...I be impressed?
There were these other MEN that made me go and see the movie again and again.
And Frodo of course can't be left out from the yummie-list. Actually, in the book Frodo was even more hot. If that's possible.

[Legolas_lover12]

well, i guess it's just the fact that frodo is about 3 ft tall and looked kinda fat (but, of course, he IS a hobbit) that made me not like him so much. hmmmm..............

[Wonko The Sane]

I was here first and I called him...sorry. But he's mine.
They're all mine.
*hoardes hot young actors*

And I went to school in South Bend, at ND. :) GO ME.

[Legolas_lover12]

NO! u can't have legolas. he's mine. i'll fight u for him!:D :D :D

[Wonko The Sane]

*kicks LL12's @$$*
I told you, I already called him.
Don't mess with me.

I win.
Final say.

[Legolas_lover12]

u can't win against me! ur just a sock!!!:D :D :D

[Wonko The Sane]

That's a low blow...
And I already did win.
:)
I have summarily deflowered all the hot actor man-boys and they are mine now.

[Legolas_lover12]

ok, u can have the actors (orlando, viggo, elijah, etc) and i'll take the characters (legolas, aragorn, frodo, etc). how's that?:D :D :D

[tasar]

There is no way you can have the characters. They're mine, MINE.

[Úlairi]

Originally posted by Wonko The Sane
That's a low blow...
And I already did win.
:)
I have summarily deflowered all the hot actor man-boys and they are mine now.

You are so full of it WTS!

[Legolas_lover12]

u so realize we're fighting over fictional characters, dont u?.............just makin sure. but anyway, back to the point..............they are MINE, MINE, MINE, MINE, MINE. (especially legolas) :D

[Wonko The Sane]

Originally posted by Ulairi


You are so full of it WTS!

Dear Ulairi,
Why are you such a jerk?

Dear Legolas_Lover12,
I know.
And they're still mine.
I also claim the actors as well.
And as I've deflowered them all you can't have them.
And that is final.
Anything you now say only proves that you're short, stubby, possessing of a beard and in love with Gimli.

The End,
Wonko The Sane

[dark_angel]

as i said before u can have the rest of the hot young actors and characters but Legolas IS mine, MINE!! MINE!!!

[Wonko The Sane]

I'm sorry. I've already laid claim to him.

Perhaps you like Legoman, or Legolam or something instead.

[Xanaphia]

hmmmmmmmmm... Sam or Aragorn? Well, I guess I have to say Sam. His loyalty is something that I can not ignore. How he was so sweet and so kind to Frodo, I just have to say he's my favorite! I've liked Aragorn ever since the book was firsttime it was read to me when I was little! He is mysterius, heroic , and a great companion to Frodo.I also like Legolas simply for all of his elven grace. O.K. maybe picking a favorite is harder than I thought because Gandalf is really neat with his wizardry, but Merry and Pippan added a lot of humar to the story, and without Borimire there'd be no excitement, and Gimli was a nice touch. Weight, I think I have it! Bill! Bill the Poney is my favorite part of the Fellowship!

[Legolas_lover12]

hmmmmmmmmmmm, short, stubby, possesing of a beard, AND in live with gimli? gee! and yuck, as well!!
how bout we make clones of them! that'd be cool! and wonko and dark_angel can fight over the originals. cuz i don't care, they'll all be the same for cryin' out loud. as long as i get a clone of legolas, frodo, aragorn, merry, and pippin!:D :D :D

[Úlairi]

Originally posted by Wonko The Sane


Dear Ulairi,
Why are you such a jerk?

Dear Legolas_Lover12,
I know.
And they're still mine.
I also claim the actors as well.
And as I've deflowered them all you can't have them.
And that is final.
Anything you now say only proves that you're short, stubby, possessing of a beard and in love with Gimli.

The End,
Wonko The Sane

I am a jerk to the people I choose.

[ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!]

Well, i voted 4 frodo cos hes soooooo cute!

[Lady Legolas]

my favorite characters from the fellowship are of course Legolas,and Aragorn...
I always loved these two characters the best when I read the books.I think both Aragorn and Legolas were portrayed very well in the movie!!
Orlando is hot!!!!!

[Frodorocks]

WTS, you're the JERK! You haven't deflowered any of the actors because who would want to do anything with you? And you definetly CAN'T have Frodo. He's mine.:p

[Oren]

Now ME!!!!!!!,
Let us not be hasty. I think we all have our reasons and that is a good one but so isnt the rest of the FOTR.

[Úlairi]

Originally posted by Frodorocks
WTS, you're the JERK! You haven't deflowered any of the actors because who would want to do anything with you? And you definetly CAN'T have Frodo. He's mine.:p

LOL FR. Cute, very cute. Seeing as you are a newbie, and I seem to like you, I won't be a jerk to you, how's that?

[tasar]

Oh my, Ulairi
You've got a picture now so that we can all see who you really are...

[Wonko The Sane]

To Ulairi: You're still a jerk.
To Frodorocks: You're also a jerk.

I didn't do anything to you...
And the hot actor men boy people DID let me deflower them? Wanna know why? Because they love me.
And that's that.
The End.

And as I said before:
Anything you now say only proves that you're short, stubby, possessing of a beard and in love with Gimli.

So you're both short, stubby, beard-wearing, Gimli lovers...

[Úlairi]

Originally posted by tasar
Oh my, Ulairi
You've got a picture now so that we can all see who you really are...

Scary, aren't I?

[Legolas_lover12]

veeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerry scary! lol!:D ;) :D ;) :rolleyes:

[Frodorocks]

Sounds cool, Ulairi.:) And WTS, I know you didn't do anything to me, but I don't like it when people are obnoxious to anybody.:rolleyes:

[Wonko The Sane]

Then it seems you should be jumping down Ulairi's throat as well as mine.

[Úlairi]

Frodorocks is a smart gal, she wouldn't dare jump down my throat. :p

[i luv hobbits]

your favourite character

Please do the poll above and tell me your fave character in LOTR :)

[YayGollum]

Gollum. Because he's the hero. :D

[uzuki]

Whos your favorite charecter i was just wondering my friends and i keep arguing about it so i want to tell them what others think

[Frodorocks]

I haven't seen Ulairi being a huge pile of frass. (butterfly poop):D :D :p :D :D

[HLGStrider]

I voted for Strider... my perfect man... I love you Strider... no!!! don't marry the elf... ELGEE LOVES YOU!!!

Boo hoo...

[Gamil Zirak]

You just can't go wrong with a dwarf so I voted for Gimli.

[Gandalf_White]

My choice is obvious. I am the first vote for Gandalf. GO ME!

You spelled Sauron wrong.

[Asmodeus]

Gandalf and Sam are the coolest cahracters!!:p

But i do like Eomer and Faramir. especially seeing as how he'll be played by David Wenham (go Aussie!, -born here):D

[Frodorocks]

And Wonko, anything YOU now say only proves that you're fat, ugly, possessing of horns, and in love with an orc.:p

[Oren]

Well in my opinion they r all cool, but if I had to choose I would choose then I would choose Sam. Who else?! Hobbits Rule! Well so dont elves...

[Bilbo Baggins57]

Sam & Frodo. I can't decide between them.

[Elu Thingol]

Legolas and Gandalf are my favorite characters.

[Úlairi]

Legolas M2003? Why's that?

[Wonko The Sane]

Frodorocks: Since I already said it to you your comment is just null.
Therefore: No.

[Lily from Bree]

Oh, Frodo by all means. He's really the bravest, even if he didn't do a lot of warrior feats. I mean, did you see Aragorn or Legolas or anyone else going into Mordor itself??? And at first he wanted to go alone!! If Sam hadn't run after him, he would have. And Frodo was the one who had to have the burden of the Ring. He took it on himself, which was heroic.

[Úlairi]

Was in Gnasher the Orc that made the thread called "Frodo the wimp."?

[zeuqirne]

i go for legolas! i fancy elves.... they are so wise and beautiful....

[Úlairi]

I haven't seen you before, but it says that you were logged on in March. Well, I guess I see someone new on the forum every day.

[Lily from Bree]

I would like to know what THAT was supposed to mean, Ulairi.

[Lily from Bree]

Frodo. I LOVE Frodo. He is the BEST!!!!!

[Beorn]

If I see this thread again...

[Wonko The Sane]

What...what's wrong with this thread Mike?

Oh, and your sig's too long...Readwryt'll kill ya.

[Legolas_lover12]

WTS - it was beorn that said that, not mike.

[ms Greenleaf]

In my opinion looking at the acting skills Gandalf is the best Legolas was not as important character but it was a difficult role and I would be bettter at judging it in the next movie where he has more lines . Aragorn also had a deep character as for female they were both done very well

[elven_warrior]

who was everyone's fav character in LOTR? i liked strider.

[Aragorn*9]

Aragorn
Elessar
Elfstone
Strider
Longshanks

[YayGollum]

Gollum (the Hero) :D

[Chymaera]

I liked Farmer Cotton ;)

[Muffinly]

Quickbeam!!!!!!!!

But he's not in FOTR

[Arien]

Legolas,Pippin,Aragorn.............in that order

[Ceorl]

Very difficult, I like all the characters, but to be different and not say the traditional Aragorn Legolas route I will say Theoden. He epitomises the meaning of a kind valiant goodly man to me.

[Nenya Evenstar]

I've always loved Arwen, been totally fascinated with Galadriel, been in love with Aragorn, and wished to be like Legolas... :D Man, that's a tough one!

[Dwarf Lord]

Gandalf is really cool, I like how he demands power as Gandalf the white, and he has such a great wealth of knowledge, and knows alot of the people in ME. He is a great friend, and a powerful enemy. Of course I also like Gimli! and I say more!



DWARF LORD

[Ringwraith VIII]

1.Gandalf
2.Aragon:confused: (however you spell it)
3.Frodo
4.Legalos
5.Gimli

[HobbitGirl]

Gandalf is definitly my favorite. He is just so cool in The Hobbit, but he never seems as merry after he found out that Bilbo's ring was the One Ring. He always seems to know what's going to happen, even if he doesn't really KNOW. Maybe it's just a wizard thing. But anyway, Gandalf is my favorite character.

[malazac]

i like legalos

[Ynhockey]

Of the main characters I'd have to say Boromir.

Of the secondary ones, definitely Theoden, but i also liked Eowyn and Galadriel.

[WhiteRingwraith]

Gandalf and Boromir!
then Aragorn

[Grond]

Grond, the battering ram that broke the gates of Minas Tirith. After all, he was named after me. :);):p

[Sarah]

I just had a change of heart, for no apparent reason, as to favorite character (not to worry, i still love gollum) but I also love Arwen. She's so pretty and brave (not to mention has a hot lover! ;) :rolleyes: ). And she can speak Elvish and sounds so pretty when she does.

[saruman]

i think the best is lrgolas beacuse legolas is the best archer in the world

[seadragon]

the elves are my favourite
legolas
galadriel
elrond
arwen

[Boromir's Lady]

Well, I guess mines obvious from my name - Boromir is my favorite (from the 'TFoTR'). The tragic hero, he was Brave, strong, reliable warrior who showed hints of his vulnerability. Sean Bean played this part beautifully!

I also liked Gandalf for his wisdom and kindness

I liked Aragorn for his leadership, courage and loyalty

I liked Frodo for being soft-spoken, innocent & faithful.

[Éomond]

Uh, um...I...Gandalf? Yeah, Gandalf, that's it!

[Eowyn711]

I thought Aragorn was deadon.......... but I could never vote... they all did a great job.. awesome

[Anthratoc]

He is the most confident character in the adventure. "confident" in everyway meaning he has the ability to improve himself by being aware of what kind of faults he can make and if does one, accepting the mistake and being able to see it. In my philosophy: power is wisdom, temperance, patience, foreseeing, etc. The only aim this combination of virtues is to lead you to the universal truth and that is in any point of the universe there is only one correct definition for anything and somehow even if the definition is awkward to a person after a thinking period, that person will logically accept it but maybe not practically. . Because of his virtues which any human can have but dont, my favorite is Gandalf.

[Legolas]

pippin cos hes so brave

[Wonko The Sane]

Pippin because everyone grabs his @$$.
He's PIMPIN!

If you watch the part right after they roll down the hill when Frodo says "GET OFF THE ROAD!" and they all jump down under that tree you'll see that to "stabilize" himself as he jumps down Frodo grabs Pippin's @$$ and then Sam reaches over and grabs Pippin's @$$ near the thigh...
Seems the only one who doesn't grab Pip, is Merry.

[Legolas_lover12]

....i don't even know how to respond to that ....:rolleyes:

[Wonko The Sane]

Grab Pippin's @$$ too...you know you want to...
I know I want to!

[Legolas_lover12]

geee .........could i ..................as tempting as that is:rolleyes: .........i think i'll pass;) .............

[Wonko The Sane]

Ooh...you're missing out...it's one of the most wonderful activities out there!

[Legolas_lover12]

ok i think this coonversation has gone on long enough. new topic please.

[mr underhill]

best in fellowship was gimli son of gloin... sure the dwarf tossin line was bad but hes cool!

Shouldve got WAY more screen time!

[Popqueen62]

Who was your favorite character in Lotr? Personally, Merry and Pippin are my favorite.

[Jav]

My personal favorit is Gollum. Too bad he isn't in the movie more. But thats why I can't wait for "The Two Towers" to come out. He is gonna play a very large role in that one.

[Anamatar IV]

aragorn. Or as mad magazine says...popcorn.

[Gil-Galad]

well,I like Gandalf.Not beacuse of LOtR,but because of UT.He is so clever and precise that the world wouldn't survive without his help.

[YayGollum]

Isn't there already a thread for this? oh well. Definitely Gollum. 'Cuz he's the hero. :D

[Stridir]

who is your fav. character?? it can be the actor, or the person. post here. i like Strider myself (huh, duh???!!!???)

[YayGollum]

Probably Gollum. 'Cuz he's fun to defend.

[Lantarion]

Heh, no need asking you Yay. :rolleyes: :)
Gandalf for me. Or Merry.

[Mithlond]

Sam's my favorite.

[Ithrynluin]

Galadriel all the way. Also:Gandalf,Elrond,Cirdan,Saruman....but I like most of them anyway.:)

[Lord Tuor]

i would have to say my favorite was glorfindel

[Hooded Ranger]

Aragorn is my fav!;) Then I would hafta pick Gandalf.

[Carantalath]

My favorite is Legolas (I decided that before I saw the movie, before you ask. I just liked the elves a lot.) or Eowyn.

[Jorg]

Gandalv the white, is my favorite character. Secret servant of the "Anors fire" :eek:

[Lantarion]

Originally posted by Jorg
Secret servant of the "Anors fire" :eek:
If you have no idea what that means, check this (http://www.thetolkienforum.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=3927&highlight=Secret+fire) out. :)

[Hume]

Mine would have to be Gimli, and then maybe Gandalf

[Theoden]

1# Theoden, 2# Sam, 3# Frodo, 4# Elijah Wood. :D

-me

[Ascamaciliel]

Legolas, Frodo, Sam, Gollum

[Elennainie]

Eowyn is my favorite, even though I like the elves the best! :)

[Finduilas]

I love elves and my favourite is Legolas.:D

[Maeglin]

Glorfindel is the best, and I would like to thank Lord Tuor for voting for him as well.;)

[Elfhelm25]

GANDALF ! GANDALF GANDALF GANDALF !
And Gimli and Legolas too !!!!!!!!!:) :) :)

[Ramagna]

My favourite is Gandalf, he has the greatest powers of all but keeps them in secret...
and although he's so wise and powerful, he can joke around with the least dangerous pepole, the hobbits...

[TheFool]

I always liked the villains more than the 'heroes', I find them so much more interesting. Give me Gollum's schizophrenic ramblings over Sam's whining about his pots and pans any day!
Saruman's the man for me, don't care much for that loser Wormtongue though.

[theLadyEowyn]

Eowyn #1 Legolas #2

[Finduilas]

I still like Legolas best!!!!!!!:)

[Isengrin]

Gandalf is surely a great caracter, cuz we learn a lot about himself with time

But... I'm like Gimli... Galadriel have steal my heart... so beautiful, so terrible and strong so Wise and so aged !

Sadly, we dont learn a lot about her in TLOTR...

But she s great, even greater than Elrond

[HLGStrider]

Aragorn. I was swept off my feet... burrr... the more I read about him the more I liked him. Now I am crazy about him... though I wasn't crazy about the movie portrayal... at least not so much. He was decent, but he wasn't my perfect Strider.

[Lossengondiel]

I'm all for my man Strider cuz he's the coolest of them all.


~~~Strider 4 ever

[Eliot]

I have a few :D

#1 Aragorn "Strider", #2 Legolas, #3 Gandalf, and #4 Eowyn.

Everybody else is pretty cool, but these are my favorites.

[Finduilas]

Although I really like Legolas,another favourite of mine is Galadriel.
She had made me adore her because of her wisdom and deep thoughts.
She undarstands every person and thats a quality to be admired.
Her personality is very strong and so is her will.She is a real queen.

[Jav]

I personally think that Gimli is awesome. I like his huge ax and I just think dwarves are cool people.

[Éomond]

Well, right now my order has changed to a tie between the three:

Gandalf, Aragorn, Boromir.

I can pick one above the other. Oh, I did like Isildur:D

[Jav]

Too bad he's not in he fellowship. :D

[Gil-Galad]

Originally posted by YayGollum
Isn't there already a thread for this? oh well. Definitely Gollum. 'Cuz he's the hero. :D
I guess you think so because it is your favourite character,not bacause you are objective in this situation.

[Manwe]

I have to say Aragorn for his burning inner desire powered by his feelings for Arwen. Although Legolas was v cool.............

[Gil-Galad]

Well,in different moments of my life I like different characters.But from some time I my favourite character is Sam.He is a character who develops himself from a quiet hobbit to a devoted friend able to do everything for his friends.He a character who never loses hope and believes in all good powers in the world.
At the same time Sam is not obliged to do anything but he sacrifices himself more than once to save his friend and master.He is ready to die not because he has a mission,but because of his feelings towards Frodo.
I really like Sam

[Jav]

Hey Gil-Galad, I feel the same way. I also like different characters at different moments of my life. I can never make my mind up. :rolleyes:

[Gil-Galad]

Originally posted by Jim
Hey Gil-Galad, I feel the same way. I also like different characters at different moments of my life. I can never make my mind up. :rolleyes:
Well I think this depends on what level of understandig of the book I'm.In the very beginnig I liked Aragorn,then Gandalf,then Frodo,and now Sam.;)

[Jav]

Yea, I guess I see what you mean. At first I liked Gollum and now I like Gimli.

[ShootingStar]

I chose Legolas because he seems to have so much strength, bravery, and integrity. (also, have you noticed how his hair never gets messed up??)

and he's cute too!!! but so is frodo!!!

[Celebthôl]

I chose Aragorn because he was human so i can relate to that and he had the power and wit to not over-powered by the rings call.

Thôl

[Dáin Ironfoot I]

Gimli has one of the biggest turn abouts in the Trilogy. He goes from hating (fearing?) Elves to being an Elf-friend himself. Gimli can be a great friend (i.e. Legolas), a friend in need (i.e. saving Eomer from death), an honest friend (i.e. his love with Galadriel) and a resourceful one (i.e. making fire). IMO, Gimli represents everything a friend should be, and represents the Fellowship the best with these friend-like qualities that he displays so well.

[Jav]

I have to agree with Dain on that one. Not only is Gimli a good, loyal friend but he is very strong as well. And I love his huge ax.

[f0enix_rising]

Preface: Forgive my "newbieisms", I just re-read LotR after ~20yrs and just saw the movie a couple weeks ago, so be gentle.

Like most people in the thread, I think all the members of the Fellowship are cool in their own ways. But, Legolas is my favorite. He's calm, gentle and at peace in nature, but whoa to those who rouse his wrath (or threaten his friend Gimli)! Plus, he's dang good w/a bow!

After him, I'd say Gandalf because of the cool wizardy things he does and then Aragorn because of his noble countenace and bravery. Also, his patience in waiting for his time to come, even though he knows who he is.


P.S. Love the forum!

[Lanaela]

I like Legolas. He's handsome, an Elf, and he has awsome skill.-Nefmariel don't call me Lanaela unless u have to

[Elendur]

Got to be Aragorn. I like him more and more the further his character is developed in the Books.

Sam / Gandalf / Frodo a close second.

[Earendil]

i would have to say gandalf...i think that the elves that aren't in the fellowship are cool too..because they are very very wise and have been through alot....

[Mablung]

Boromir is my favorite. He was always the optimist that the humans could win the war against evil. I also think that without his father's will for him to return to Minas Tirith he would have also followed Frodo to the end (without the ring exerting it's power over him of course)

[Éowyn2]

Voted for Boromir, 'cause he is the most human of 'em all. In the movie Sean Bean is the best. In the book I liked Sam most, but Sean Astin sucks in the movie.

[Aragorns_girl00]

by far aragorn!!

[quickbeam]

Does anyone find Gandalf arrogant? In my opinion, sometimes he gives the impression of being full of himself.

[Nefmariel]

he's sometimes that way but he's so cool! But my favorite by far is Legolas.

[*Lady Aragorn*]

i love aragorn!!!!!! he is so herioc and manly and hot....

[MrFrodo]

Merry and Pippin are great ....... but in combat style it goes to Legolas

[lossenandunewen]

looks like legolas is the popular one. but i voted for him too

in the books he seems so knowledgable and helpful and just an all around renaissance man, but in the movie he seems like an airhead to me, probably because of the fact that he has about 6 lines in both movies combined, but i guess orlando bloom is just a kinda ditz in a way.. don't get me wrong, i think he does a good portrayl, or atleast looks the part, but he must not be found to important if all his lines were unimportant for the movie plot, either that or he can't read. i don't know. i wonder why they make him so unimportant in the first 2 movies

[gandalfthegreat]

Gandalf...I am sure you could of guessed that is who I would of picked. Come on he is Gandalf. Without Gandalf, the fellowship wouldn't be the same, if it was even around at all. He is the one who holds the group together.

*-Gandalf-*

[AirforceBrat]

i don't know if this has alredy been a subject and i am sorry if ti is but i just want to know your opinion
thats all

[*Lady Arwen*]

I voted for Aragorn and Legolas, my favorite in the fellowship;)

[redline2200]

I voted for Gimli, because to me he was the most intriguing.

[Feänor]

I thought the hobbits were cool in FotR. They added more than a touch of humor to an otherwise gloomy tale. I'm not sure what the trilogy would have been without hobbits. :D

[Ithrynluin]

I prefer Gandalf to the rest. I was always fascinated by his beginnings, and what kind of being he is (before reading the Sil etc.).

[Feänor]

Gandalf was a Maia, right?

[BlackCaptain]

Yes. And wasnt there JUST a thread about this? oh well... i choose Sam

[AirforceBrat]

WELL EXCUSE ME! I didn't know there was already thread about it. so chill outok discussing the same thing in more then one place is completely okay. any agreements there?

[Grond]

Originally posted by AirforceBrat
WELL EXCUSE ME! I didn't know there was already thread about it. so chill outok discussing the same thing in more then one place is completely okay. any agreements there? Actually, it is not okay. Creation of threads takes much more disc space than contributing to one that is already open... so we moderators seek to combine threads that are similar. It is also against forum policy to go "off topic" so 1) stay on topic and 2) report any threads that are repeats so that they may be merged with the duplicate threads.

[Lady_of_Gondor]

Id have to say that Sam was my favorite. But this was a tough question because at different points in the story I like different characters for different reasons. The only reason I voted for same exclusively was because he was the one who stood out in my mind as the most noble character. But that certainly can be argued about to no end. I guess I just like him!

[33Peregrin]

This is a really tough decision, but I had to choose Frodo. I just think he is the best, out of the whole Fellowship. I think Pippin is the funniest, Aragorn is the coolest, and Gandalf is great. It was a really hard choice. I always feel bad for leaving Sam out, and Merry. And of course, Gimli and Legolas. And then of course Boromir is awesome too. I still must choose Frodo.:)

[Sephiroth]

Boromir is my favourite, he's just so....real , you know

[balrog]

I woul have to say Gollum !

[Theoden_king]

Boromir and Theoden both fine examples of how proud men can be

[Jesse]

Mine's easy to figure out. Gandalf and Legalos. They rock as a team!

[Elendil01]

Who is your favorite member of The Fellowship of the Ring.

[Aglarthalion]

Well, I like each member of the Fellowship in their own various ways, but if I had to choose an overall favourite, it would be Frodo.

[BlackCaptain]

There has already been a thread about this... and a poll. Try a search next time... But i'd say either Gandalf or Sam

[legolasismine]

Its easy for me...Pippin,I just always liked him and merry and frodo but second best would be Legolas.

[Lady_of_Gondor]

Sam is my favorite because he is the most loyal to Frodo and the quest.

[elf boy]

I like Gandalf cause he's kinda mysterious... Legolas is cool too though (but so is everyone in the fellowship).

[Sam_Gamgee]

GO SAM.......... YES WERE IN SECOND

[Jesse]

I think Gandalf was the best person in the Fellowship of the Ring. He was wise, brave, a good leader, and intelligent. It HAS to be Gandalf.:)

[Wonko The Sane]

Merry.
He's soo underrated.

[ely]

Well, my favourite member of the Fellowship would be Legolas because he's an Elve (I KNOW that the singular of elves is elf, but I really like elve a lot :D so if anyone doesn't have anything against it, I'll use it now and always) and I just like Elves. :D

[Boromir]

I like Boromir the best, just because he's noble and he's strong (He's weak minded though). I think that Boromir could have beaten all those orcs at Amon hin. I don't care what you say, but Boromir was not evil, he was just tempted by the ring.:p

[TaranisCain]

Aragorn

[legandir]

Sam is everything one can aspire to be: steadfast, sincere, dedicated to his friendship and quest.
He was so important it is almost ironic to think that the only reason he was told to go w/ Frodo was his eavesdropping during Gandalf's explanation of the Ring to frodo.

He is a great character who gets so much out the journey, and he still has time to woo Rosie in the end...

[Arebeth]

So people don't seem to like Frodo that much... He's not "fascinating" as I might say (in the end, maybe...). It's just nice and nobody cares of being nice, obviously- I vote for Aragorn. Quite a charisma, this guy. A real King.

[Roilya]

i chose legolas, he is just cool, its mainly because he is an elf, and uses a bow. long live the bow!

[Aulë]

Gimli.

Dwarves are so overlooked in these sorts of things...;)

[robbie]

id really would have to say Frodo,hes a hobbit(my personal favorite of all the middle earth races) plus it seems like his character really identifies with a lot of readers too.

[Wonko The Sane]

Just a question, but do we really need ANOTHER who is your favourite in the fellowship poll?

These things get tiring...:(

[treebeardgarden]

Gimli is my favorite within the fellowship.

He is gruff, quick to anger against the orcs (who I hate), an excellent judge of what is fair and not, quick to smile though we can't often see it (to much facial hair), and lastly very staunch in the support of his friends I could go on but no point in boring everyone.

[MrFrodo]

Frodo

He proves even the smallest guy can have a biggest effect :)

[Palando]

I liked all of the characters. I voted for Sam, simply because he always stuck by Frodo no matter what, and just turned out to be a great hero.
Close seconds were Merry and Boromir, because Merry realized that you can't just hide and wait for everything else to be destroyed. Boromir knew that he could not handle the power of the ring, and he would be swayed, so instead he fought to protect his friends and ended up falling.

[Ithilwen]

I like Boromir, because he defends Merry and Pippin, and I think that shows how much the three of them liked each other. Also, I am a total Faramir fan, so since Faramir wasn't in TFOTR, I had to go with his brother, because they really do look alike, except for a few differences.

[King Aragorn]

Aragorn!!!!! Because he's my favorite and I like him. :D

[Ingwë]

I voted for Gandalf... It seems to me that he was the most important of the Fellowship. Well, they're all important, of course, but Gandalf is the source. He told Frodo about the Ring and if Gand wasn't there there wouldn't be Fellowship :(

[Arlina]

Yah Aragorn!! I believe that he's the best because he took over when Gandalf was "unable" and he kept the fellowship together...plus he became King!

[ingolmo]

Gando is the best. He is the true hero of the third age and is simply great. Great, great, great. :D :D

[Berserker]

Gandalf. He's so wise, powerful, a great warrior and I've always been a great fan of wizards and magicians.

Gandalf is a perfect example of experience, knowledge, courage and friendship.

[Sherry]

I voted for Aragon.I think he is a born leader and a born king.He is prepared to shoulder any heavy burden and he is very strong and handsome.:D