Who would win a fight?

[Gary Gamgee]

Girl fight who would win? My own choice is Eowyn. On the battle fields of pellinor she was brilliant, but Galadreil would be a mean foe.

[Hanne]

Eowyn ofcourse!!!She can fight,it's in the book!!!!Can you see Galadriel FIGHING??Maybe a she would say some spel or so,but fighting?And Arwen?She may fight when she really has to (to protect Frodo,for example) but i don't think she is trained for fighting!!!

[Rohansangel]

GO EOWYN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Rohansangel]

Actually, I rethink now ... Eowyn may be a good warrior ... But who has a Ring of Power? Galadriel. I think that she would probably win, but without her Ring the battle would go to Eowyn.

~The Angel of Rohan

[Hanne]

A Ring of power is cheating!!!Without the Ring Galadriel would lose!!

[Camille]

Lobelia Sackville-Baggins will smitew them all with her umbrella :D :D :D :D

[Arwen]

Well Galadriel would destroy the lot of them, she can easily just use magic to kill them in a second, she does carry a ring.
BUT if you mean a physical fight than Galadriel would be killed first, Eowyn would be a strong fighter and although Arwen seems like she fights ONLY when she needs too and may only know basic moves...i think she COULD have a chance of beating Eowyn becuase her being an elv gives her a bit of a boost with agility and speed.

[Turgon]

I'm with Camille - Lobelia all the way!!!

[Úlairi]

It's fairly obvious. Eowyn would win!

[Sam_Gamgee]

i think eowyn is the definint winner even though i voted for lobelia because shes a mean chick, she'd would rip your head off, and galadriel could if she wanted but shes too Queenly, and arwen is a nothing compared to those girls.

[Rangerdave]

Her mother-name was Nerwen (Man-Maiden) and she grew tall even beyond the measure even of the women of the Noldor; She was strong of body, mind and will, a match for both the loremasters and athletes of the Eldar in the days of their youth.
Unfinished Tales: The History of Galadriel and Celeborn

That says enough for me to back Galadriel in a physical confrontation. She's tough and smart, a deadly mixture indeed. All would fight with valour and courage, but in the end there can be only she who was first among them.

Of course she would mourn their passing and compose a song that would be sung as long as the Halls of Mandros endured.

RD.

Besides, she cuter

[Turgon]

Come on RD, let's be serious here, are you seriously trying to say that Galadriel was better-looking than Lobelia S.B? That's just crazy talk!;)

[Rangerdave]

Brilliant! I almost fell of my chair.

I like em tall, what can I say.
but I know from experience that umbrellas can hurt alot, so she may just have a chance.

[Úlairi]

Don't forget RD, Galadriel had Nenya, one of the three, and she was the mightiest of all Noldor in ME going for her, but in UT it says on page 511:

"Galadriel, the greatest of the Eldar surviving in Middle-earth, was potent mainly in wisdom and goodness, as a director or counsellor in the struggle, unconquerable in resistance (especially in mind and spirit) but incapable of punitive action."

So, therefore Galadriel had no might in arms so I believe in a fight Eowyn would win in the actual fighting part of it, but who knows what power Galadriel had up her sleeves with Nenya on her finger.

[Rangerdave]

Ah yes.
But the greatest of victories is gained by words not arms.
She may not be able to inflilct punitive damage, but She could defeat her opponents by less violent means.

Strip poker perhaps
RD

Eww Lobelia naked. (shudder)

[Turgon]

lol! Galadriel - strip poker? That's the last thing I want to be thinking of before I turn in for the night!
Lobelia Naked? Wow! this is getting too much for me!

[Úlairi]

None of that on the forum thankyou Rangerdave! LOL

[Elias]

I think that when Lobelia gets angry you don't wanna be around. What I have read I think she is a crazy little woman and she would definitely beat the others.:p

[tasar]

Noone could resist Galadriel. Her power is inside her even without the ring. She would look straight into the hearts of her opponents and she could become real mean, if she wanted.

[Anamatar IV]

Eowyn. She is good enough to pass as a man? :D In the TTT trailor you saw her kick aragorns ass! :)

[Gary Gamgee]

:p Lobelia is kicking Arwen's head in and Galadriel is begining to look worried. hee hee hee

[Úlairi]

LOL. Galadriel would not beat Eowyn, as Galadriel had no might in arms, I gave reasons on the previous page.

[Legolam]

I think Arwen would fight dirty though. Long nails scratching and pulling hair and all that. Eowyn would have too much honour, Galadriel would moan about passing a test and Lobelia would just try and stab people with her umbrella. :D

[Úlairi]

Eowyn all the way.

[Aredhel]

Definitly Eowyn. Galadriel and Arwen may be High Elves, but they don't know how to fight with weapons(in the book) and Eowyn does.

[Úlairi]

I mean, how could it not be Eowyn?

[Arwen]

Originally posted by Legolam
I think Arwen would fight dirty though. Long nails scratching and pulling hair and all that. Eowyn would have too much honour, Galadriel would moan about passing a test and Lobelia would just try and stab people with her umbrella. :D

He he he thats pretty funny....

[Gary Gamgee]

I want to add Shelob to the poll. How would you vote if she where there?

[Úlairi]

Then I cahnge my vote to Shelob, no problems.

[Ithrynluin]

GALADRIEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Úlairi]

SHELOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Minas]

I know this wasnt the original question bbbbuuuuttt... whi would be first ti get their gears off in strip poker? I'm for the Baggins having the umbrella open first...

[Úlairi]

LOL

[Gary Gamgee]

Yay Shelob's been added to the poll. Thank you.

The idea of Lobelia stripping is enough to make the others admit defeat and leg it.