"What if...?" - workbook

[Lhunithiliel]

This the place where all who wish, can express opinions, comments etc. concerning the "What if?" - game.

We can use this thread to suggest and discuss new topics, to make suggestions about the development of the stories etc.. ...

Well, this is going to be the "workbook" of the game.
Thus, the game itself will not be interrupted by commentaries etc.
Now we have the place for this!

Use it well! ;) :D

[spirit]

I have a "What if..." idea, but I'm not sure if it has already been mentioned before. Here it is anyway: :)
What if the ring had never sat quietly in the Shire, but instead have been noticed by Gandalf for what the Ring truely was. What would happen?

[Lhunithiliel]

Thank's Spirit for the idea! :D
Do you think we can make a good exciting and not too long story out of it? I think we can.
You can start .. we'll follow.
BTW HERE'S (http://www.thetolkienforum.com/showthread.php?t=16065) THE ARCHIVES OF THE PREVIOUS GAMES, so you can have a best idea of what the WIG is. :)

All, right, let's give it a try!

But!!!
The story is to start and develop in the main thread , of course! :)

[cylindk]

What if the One Ring was not destroyed...