Discussion in '"The Lord of the Rings"' started by flame, Nov 14, 2002.
is there a rank for a wizard that is black , like gandalf the gery, like that.
no. There were only five istari on middle earth:
Blue: Pollando and alatar.
Well I guess you could call Sauron "The Black", but he was never called that, so it doesn't matter.
The colourizations that occur in Tolkien's world are meant only to rank the Istari in order of power and aura. As the colour black is almost always a colour of 'evil' or terror or the like, I don't think any Istar would use that pseudonym, as they were all good guys (except Saruman, but he was good before he flipped out).
It is correct that (originally) Saruman was the white, Gandalf the grey and Radagast the brown wizard. However I would like to mention that Tolkien AFAIK did not make a final decision about the names of the "Blue Wizards" (Alatar and Pallando or Morinehtar and Rómestámo [or Róme(n)star] were only names Christopher found on some rapid jottings (partly illegible) of his father). (c.f. What are the names of the Blue Wizards?)
And the names of the "Black Wizards" - if there were any - could be Jake and Elwood... (or should that say "Black Blues Wizards"?)
why is there five wizaerd if two dont have names.
because 2 of them were hardly ever mentioned.
Sauron coulve been called the black wizard if he was one of the five. He was just a maia. If he was not an istari, he was not a wizard/
Gandalf himself ranks (sort of) the colors. After he comes back and meets Aragorn, Gimli and Legolas he says, "I am Gandalf, Gandalf the White, but black is mightier still.
No, he was talking about its ability to resist stains. Tee hee...
Just posting in appriciation of the Jake and Elwood joke...
"We're on a mission... from Illuvatar."
Well actually there were more than 5 of them total: From Unfinished Tales: The Istari
That is referring to the entire Heren Istarion (order of wizards). But anyway, I doubt that any of the unknown ones had the color black, who knows if they were even ranked by color.
I didn't say there were only 5 anywhere in my post, now did I?
But when you've read the chapter about the Istari in UT you know almost everything there is to know about them, there are only a few pieces of information left out, most of which is covered in HoMe12, a small chapter named "The Five Wizards" where Christopher provides us with some additional information about them.
Oh and, the part of the black wizards was a joke as some may have noticed (and which has it's roots in another thread about the Istari)...
...well, unless I overlooked something, where Tolkien actually mentioned Jake and Elwood...
ha ha no I don't think Tolkien ever mentioned them, I read that joke in the other thread too. Oooh ooh I have an idea! make an RPG with Jake and Elwood as Istari!
That's an RP I'd like to join... Can I be the girl friend with the Machine gun? I'm almost as short as Carrie Fischer and I know all of her lines from Star Wars!
lol at the blues wizards..
Separate names with a comma.