My question surrounds the choice to be man or elven in Earendil's bloodline. Elrond and Elros were his children both of which were able to choose. Subsequently however, Arwen was able to choose but no one from Elros' line was which is why I am curious. So when Manwe said that this kindred may freely choose their fates, does Manwe just mean Elrond and Elros? Thus making Arwen's choice the result of something unrelated? Or maybe once Elros chose to be man his decedents lost their choice? Or maybe it was a continuity error? Id love to know what you all think. Im a fairly newby Toliken fan so I might not have the background to understand it quite yet.