Round 7: Guild of the Periaur vs. Guild of Tolkienology

Discussion in 'Debates' started by Bethelarien, Sep 11, 2003.

  1. Bethelarien

    Bethelarien The Lost Evenstar

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    1,005
    Likes Received:
    4
    Trophy Points:
    36
    Location:
    Ost Tel`Eldalie
    Home Page:
    I apologize to both teams for the delay in putting this thread up. My life has been extremely hectic lately, and I was only asked to host this debate a couple of days ago. My sincere apologies for any inconveniences.

    Once both sides have posted their teams, I'll put up a topic.

    Judges for this debate round:

    GoE/D: Bethelarien
    GoO: Nom
    GoS: baragund
    OiE: Arvedui
    Neutral: Talierin
     
    Last edited: Sep 25, 2003
  2. Celebthôl

    Celebthôl Loremaster

    Joined:
    Oct 2, 2002
    Messages:
    2,413
    Likes Received:
    3
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Tis okay, no harm done :)

    The Periaur team will consist of:

    ~Aulë~
    ~Snaga~
    ~Legolam~ (I think)
    ~Celebthôl~


    If it is not Legolam, ill edit it when i find out. . .
     

  3. Aulë

    Aulë The Larrikin

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2002
    Messages:
    2,988
    Likes Received:
    6
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Agronomist/Researcher
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    You are correct, my young debating padawan, as Legolam is on our team. :)
    You learn quickly. :)
     
  4. Beleg

    Beleg Fading

    Joined:
    Jan 10, 2003
    Messages:
    1,473
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Home Page:
    Beleg
    Finduilas
    Anamatar
    ManvEru
     

  5. Bethelarien

    Bethelarien The Lost Evenstar

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    1,005
    Likes Received:
    4
    Trophy Points:
    36
    Location:
    Ost Tel`Eldalie
    Home Page:
    I have PMed the topic to Maedhros and await his approval.
     
  6. Aulë

    Aulë The Larrikin

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2002
    Messages:
    2,988
    Likes Received:
    6
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Agronomist/Researcher
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    Well....?
     
  7. Bethelarien

    Bethelarien The Lost Evenstar

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    1,005
    Likes Received:
    4
    Trophy Points:
    36
    Location:
    Ost Tel`Eldalie
    Home Page:
    The Topic

    The Silmarillion, Chapter 19: Of Beren and Luthien

    Was Thingol right to impose the Quest of the Silmaril upon Beren?

    Since the GoP is the home team, they may choose the side of the debate and begin.
     
  8. Celebthôl

    Celebthôl Loremaster

    Joined:
    Oct 2, 2002
    Messages:
    2,413
    Likes Received:
    3
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Just a quick observation, a certain young debater ancious to get away is using under-handed tactics to get a head start. . . three guesses as to who, though you will only need one :rolleyes:.

    I believe for this abomination, the GoT should forfeit a member. ;)
     
  9. Snaga

    Snaga The Usual Suspect

    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2002
    Messages:
    2,261
    Likes Received:
    5
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Home Page:
    Let's get this show on the road.

    The position of the Periaur is that Thingol was wrong to impose the Quest of the Silmaril on Beren.

    I'll summarise the reasons in this post, and my colleagues and I can go into more detail as the debate unfolds.

    The reasons come down to this: that Thingol selfishly attempted to thwart the love of Beren and Luthien, in a manner that he believed to be devious. But this scheme failed in its design, in that it didnt prevent the union of Beren and Luthien. Moreover it put in motion events that lead to the ruin of Doriath, and the death of Thingol itself.

    Our opponents will doubtless argue that the recovery of the Silmaril was a great achievement that would never have happened without Thingol's action. But he never intended Beren to succeed. Quite the reverse - he never expected to see Beren alive again. We should honour Beren and Luthiens for their deeds, not credit Thingol for his deviousness.

    Perhaps too they will say it was instrumental in allowing the Voyage of Earendil to succeed, and thus the intervention of the Valar that finally defeated Morgoth. But this argument, while superficially appealing, doesnt stand up. Why? Because these event, long after Thingols time were the achievement of the descendents of Beren and Luthien, whose marriage he aimed to prevent. They were far after his time, and concern matters which he had never consciously tried to influence.

    Thingol had always tried to stay out of the Wars of the Noldor. But his action, in laying the Quest of the Silmaril upon Beren, meant this was no longer viable. The consequence of the Silmaril arriving in Doriath are well known: the war with the dwarves, and the attack of the sons of Feanor.

    But more fundamental than all this we will show that Thingol's attitude to Beren was unjustified and unwise. He sought to send Beren to his death, for the 'crime' of loving his daughter. For a man who was a valiant elf-friend to be treated in this way cannot be condoned.

    - It was wrong to try to thwart the love of Beren and Luthien.
    - It was wrong to treat Beren like a criminal, and to try to send him to his death.
    - It lead to the ruin of Doriath and the death of Thingol himself.
    - Thingol's intentions came to nothing.
    - Any good that came out of it was in spite of Thingol, and not because of him.

    These are our reasons for saying that Thingol was wrong. Over to you, Tolkienologists!:)
     
  10. Lhunithiliel

    Lhunithiliel Fëanorean

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2002
    Messages:
    3,138
    Likes Received:
    7
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    translator
    I am sorry to intrude here, but as Thol IS a member of the GoT as well.......... hmmmmmmmmm........... does he have the right to participate in the present debate AGAINST the GoT?
    Thol? :confused:

    Besides, I need to know what you mean by:
    Will you please?

    Thank you and good luck to both teams.....AFTER the above matters have been arranged.
     
  11. Aulë

    Aulë The Larrikin

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2002
    Messages:
    2,988
    Likes Received:
    6
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Agronomist/Researcher
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    Lhun,
    Thol was a member of the GotP before he joined the GoT.
    And do not forget people like Beth and Scatha, who are apart of GoT too, yet you allow them to debate...

    I believe that Thol was jokingly referring to Anamatar, who contacted him on MSN, pretending to be on the Periaur team to gather 'inside information'.
     
  12. Celebthôl

    Celebthôl Loremaster

    Joined:
    Oct 2, 2002
    Messages:
    2,413
    Likes Received:
    3
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Yes, what he said. . . if you had got to me before Aulë i would be debating for GoT, but hes excedingly quick to round up a team. . . :( sowwy.
     
  13. Lhunithiliel

    Lhunithiliel Fëanorean

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2002
    Messages:
    3,138
    Likes Received:
    7
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    translator
    Thol, I do NOT object to your membership in the GoT, you know it!

    But ..... ain't it .... a bit strange ... a member of our Guild - debating against the Guild itself?

    I think, the situation could be solved simply by replacing Thol with another debator. Thol can of course debate in any other case when such a contradiction does not exist.

    Aule, Scatha and Beth were not allowed to debate agaist the GoT and Scatha was even dismissed from judging a debate for being a member of the GoT.

    But..... don't misunderstand me.... I, personally, do not have anything against all that. The debating tournament is a wonderful opportunity for exchanging knowledge!It really does NOT matter which guild one belongs to.

    It's only that such situations are to be probably discussed and a suitable solution should be found.
    I know that C9 has permitted it for a TTF-er to be a member of more than one Guild. Fine! But when it comes to debating between guilds.... then ?????
    :confused:
     
  14. Aulë

    Aulë The Larrikin

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2002
    Messages:
    2,988
    Likes Received:
    6
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Agronomist/Researcher
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    Beth and Scatha both debated against the GoT in Round 5.
    I don't see why you're suddenly complaining about this. You're creating a storm in a teacup.:rolleyes:
    Sometimes I get the feeling that the GoT try to create trouble in their debates....;)

    Maybe it would be better if this convo continued in the DT Discussion thread?
     
  15. Manveru

    Manveru (former)blue angel of GoT

    Joined:
    Jun 12, 2003
    Messages:
    1,070
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    ...
    Location:
    Edinburgh
    Home Page:
    Seize fire... both sides... it's pointless

    No trouble meant... Are we cool here?

    I'd like to say only that we'll post our "opener" later today (read: as soon as I get it confirmed from all my teammates).

    Patience would be appreciated. THX:D

    BTW: Lhun, Aule's got a point about Scatha...
    And I'd really like to see this 'silly' battle about Thol closed... For Eru's sake, the boy will be unable to debate in the end... because of a nervous breakdown! (I'm kidding:D I know it won't happen;)).
     
  16. Snaga

    Snaga The Usual Suspect

    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2002
    Messages:
    2,261
    Likes Received:
    5
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Home Page:
    Hmm... perhaps you have a point. Thol has divided loyalties... perhaps he will be a handicap to our team. Perhaps he will deliberately post badly to undermine the Periaur cause.... *thinks carefully* But I think we'll take the risk. But thank you for your concern, Lhun. Its nice that you are trying to win fair and square. Here's to fair and honest debate!:)
     
  17. Manveru

    Manveru (former)blue angel of GoT

    Joined:
    Jun 12, 2003
    Messages:
    1,070
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    ...
    Location:
    Edinburgh
    Home Page:
    A glass can be half-empty or half-full. It depends on how one sees it.;)
    Seems like a "one-sided" question, but only at first... (see a top of this post;)).
    We, Tolkienologists, would argue that Thingol was right in doing so. Why?
    The opposing team put some suppositions (totally missed IMHO) as to what would be our "course" of debating (are you guys playing oracles or just guessing...:rolleyes: ). Doesn't matter... You forgot about one "tiny" detail that is: FATHER'S LOVE.
    From Of the Sindar:
    From Of Beren and Luthien:
    And mark this also. Thingol didn't know Beren. And he also wasn't fond of Men (as a race in general). He needed sth (a proof) that this "child of little lords and brief kings" (as he named him in his thought) was worthy of a "price" which his hand reached out for. I know, I know... I hear already your wild cries like: "But Thingol never expected to see Beren again! He sent him to an inevitable death!". That's right. But then again Beren nearly 'gave' the idea himself:
    Could Thingol have thought of a better 'trial' than that...

    - Thingol loved his daughter more than ANYTHING in the world.
    - Beren, his achievements or the deeds of his father meant nothing to Thingol in this matter.
    - He wanted to see if Beren was worthy of the "price". After all, it wasn't a dispute about some sword or other reward (be it of the greatest value). She was a king's daughter, his "only child", for Eru's sake!
    - The Quest was, in some way, equal to the reward (though Thingol still considered himself to be generous).

    These are our reasons for that Thingol was right to impose the Quest of the Silmaril upon Beren.
     
  18. Celebthôl

    Celebthôl Loremaster

    Joined:
    Oct 2, 2002
    Messages:
    2,413
    Likes Received:
    3
    Trophy Points:
    38
    *breaks down nervously* :D J/K ;)

    On the final word on this stuff, i will do my best for the Periaur, and i will debate for GoT next time these two teams meet. :) How's that?
     
  19. Lhunithiliel

    Lhunithiliel Fëanorean

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2002
    Messages:
    3,138
    Likes Received:
    7
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    translator
    Do whatever you want!
     
  20. Aulë

    Aulë The Larrikin

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2002
    Messages:
    2,988
    Likes Received:
    6
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Agronomist/Researcher
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    Interesting...interesting....
    It is amazing how selective quoting makes it seem that way....:rolleyes: Beware, judges, as the Tolkienologists are trying to make fools out of you by taking Tolkien's words out of context. ;)
    Perhaps we should 'fill in the gaps', and reveal what Thingol was really thinking? Hmmm?

    Indeed Thingol loved his daughter, and because of this he was prepared to make an oath that he would not kill Beren.
    But under no circumstances was he prepared to allow Lúthien to marry Beren, and he became angered at Beren's words and regretted his oath, so he got around his promise by sending Beren on a quest which appeared to be impossible/suicidal to prevent Beren from marrying Lúthien.
    Manveru seems to think that the given task was a 'trial' of sorts, to see if Beren was worthy. I think not.

    Once Thingol had named his 'price':
    Thingol had sent Beren to his death.
    The wise Sindar of Doriath perceived this, as did the Ainur Melian. Thingol had been cunning, and had seemingly gotten rid of Beren, whilst keeping his promise to Lúthien. As Thingol states, he would not give up his daughter for any treasure (including the Silmaril). So why would he apparently exchange his daughter for the Silmaril? It seems as if Thingol sent Beren on a quest which would claim his life. If Thingol had thought that Beren could retrieve the Silmaril and return with it to Menegroth, he would not have traded his daughter for it, even if Beren was the only one in the world who could have snatched it from Morgoth's grasp. Thingol even says that he would have killed Beren (and broken his oath to Lúthien) if there was a chance of him returning.

    This last quote also adds more wood to this fire that is this debate, as it shows that Thingol brought the Doom of Mandos upon himself and his people.

    Not something that you would want given to you...



    Now, indeed Thingol loved his daughter more than anything else, but one thinks that he took this love too far. Sure, he wanted to protect Lúthien: he did not want her marrying a mortal, but Lúthien loved Beren.
    Indeed, this was what Thingol was concerned about. He wanted to protect Lúthien from that fate.
    But Lúthien was no fool by any means. She would have known of the consequences of a marriage between herself and Beren. But she was prepared to make that sacrifice.
    Thingol should have respected Lúthien's decision. That would have shown true love to his daughter.
    Instead, he threw her opinions out of the window, and decided for himself what her 'best interests' were. But were they? No.
    Thingol was not right to impose the quest apon Beren. He was being over-protective, and virtually sent Beren to his doom to do so.
    Perhaps he could have pleaded with Lúthien to think of her future, as to prevent the marriage, yet spare Beren's life? And perhaps he did, to no avail?
    But either way, his decision was wrong. Lúthien had accepted the price of marrying Beren, and Thingol should have realised this.