which is better? Children of hurin or The silmarillion?

Discussion in '"The Children of Húrin"' started by Master of maps, Apr 25, 2008.

?

which is better? the children of hurin or the silmarillion?

  1. the silmarillion

    81.3%
  2. the children of hurin

    18.8%
  1. Lady_of_Gondor

    Lady_of_Gondor CityMaiden

    Joined:
    Mar 22, 2002
    Messages:
    113
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    ESL Teacher in France
    Location:
    Le Mans, France
    Home Page:
    I voted for the Children of Hùrin because it was more approachable and readable for me. But that is not because I think that the Silmarillion is not a worthwhile read. I loved it. I just think that CoH would be a good initiation into the larger framework of Middle Earth for somebody who has only read the Lord of the Rings. I think so, not only because Christopher Tolkien says so in his forward to the book, but also because I found it a much easier read than the Silmarillion, and because it is smaller in scope, it is a good test for if you would have the patience to delve into the deeper stuff or if you would prefer to remain a Hobbit/LotR only kind of fan.
     
  2. Bucky

    Bucky Registered User

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2001
    Messages:
    1,624
    Likes Received:
    11
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Location:
    Near New Haven
    Home Page:
    Quote:
    from the Blue Wizard
    "especially keeping in mind that Of Turin Turambar is my least favorite part of The Sil."

    Like Illuin, I too found that comment interesting because I always like 'Of Turin Turambar' the best in The Silmarillion.

    You know, the dragon & all.....

    I also agree with everyone that CoH is a more traditional read with the dialogue & also the depth of detail that we are more used to in the Hobbit & TLOR.
     

  3. Húrin

    Húrin Registered User

    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2009
    Messages:
    3
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    I would prefer not to judge between them. The Silmarillion is an incredible tale spanning thousands of years of the history of Arda; The Children of Hurin is focused on one part it. Both are masterful and beautiful works. :)
     
  4. Ingwë

    Ingwë Creeping Death

    Joined:
    Aug 30, 2004
    Messages:
    934
    Likes Received:
    3
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Student
    Location:
    Aarhus, Denmark
    Home Page:
    I agree. I can't say which one is better because The Children Of Hurin is a part of The Silmarillion. It is like saying which one is better: a single chapter of the book or the whole book.
     

  5. Môrroch

    Môrroch Horse-lord of Rohan

    Joined:
    Jun 12, 2009
    Messages:
    14
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Advertising
    Location:
    Sunny Southern Wisconsin
    My sentiments as well. The Children Of Hurin is a focus and expansion on one small but significant area of the larger history given by the Silmarillion. I enjoyed seeing the tale more fully developed.
     
  6. Illuin

    Illuin Fire On The Mountain

    Joined:
    May 7, 2008
    Messages:
    1,016
    Likes Received:
    3
    Trophy Points:
    0
    The Silmarillion blows Children of Húrin away; hands down!

    Come on - Beren and Lúthien; Fëanor and the Silmarils; Ungoliant and the Two Trees, Fingolfin and Morgoth, The Voyage of Eärendil; The Fall of Gondolin, The War of Wrath.

    And of course there is Akallabêth. Getting so into the Second Age lately. It's so mysterious and unknown, yet so atmospheric. CoH was great, but there is no comparison. The Silmarillion is infinitely supreme. Every line is lyrical and deep, and the prose are poetic and elegant.
     
  7. EdBurke

    EdBurke Registered User

    Joined:
    Dec 11, 2009
    Messages:
    14
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Student (Lazy)
    Location:
    Ireland
    I though the Children of Hurin was miles better, mainly because its a novel and the silmarillion is more like a dramatised history book. Either way, while the silmarillion is a somewhat complex weavings of various narrative threads, the Children of Hurin is uncomplicated and sincere. Its a rivetting story with a tragic ending. (Its no rival to LOTR... but you know what I mean)
     
  8. Elbereth

    Elbereth Star Queen of Valinor

    Joined:
    Jan 22, 2002
    Messages:
    1,024
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    36
    Occupation:
    Former Event Planner / Current Full Time Mommy
    Location:
    Just west of Middle Earth..(aka: NJ)
    Home Page:
    I voted the Silmarillion because to me it had much more depth to it than the Children of Hurin. I also loved the fact that it held so much of the history of middle earth in it....it gave me more insight into the world that I fell in love with in the Lord of the Rings....you can't beat that!
     
  9. Galentir

    Galentir Ranger of the Dunedain

    Joined:
    Jan 17, 2010
    Messages:
    15
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Photographer
    Location:
    HertfordSHIRE, England
    Home Page:
    Its The Silmarillion for me! All the flavour of the Greek Myths, the Norse Sagas and the Old Testament combined in an original Creation Myth with Folk Wanderings and ethnic cleansing thrown in. Elves in LoTR come across as ethereal goodies - in the Sil they are all sorts - good, bad, greedy, vain, selfish etc .. Just like us.

    Children of Hurin just depressed me and I wonder why it was published between its own covers. You can read it in the Sil and in the Lost Tales. Is there a danger that the sacred cow will be milked too often by Young Christopher? If only JRR had completed the alliterative poem form, then it would have stood comparison with Sigurd and Gudrun. Such a loss to literature
     
  10. Eledhwen

    Eledhwen Cumbrian

    Joined:
    May 11, 2002
    Messages:
    3,145
    Likes Received:
    43
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Occupation:
    Special Educational Needs for 15-16 year olds
    Location:
    Royal Wootton Bassett, Wiltshire, England, UK
    Home Page:
    Anyone who has read this in the Silmarillion first, can't possibly judge. Reading a story for the first time, in what Tolkien called its "first bloom" will always be more gripping; more exciting. I bought and read The Children of Hurin, and loved the fact that the story had been published in its own right - holding the book, opening it and reading it. But it has to be said that I already knew how it ended, and that is a detraction.

    I would like to hear the opinions of people who did not know the story before, and read it for the first time in its own publication.
     
  11. Ciryaher

    Ciryaher Witch of Resurrection

    Joined:
    Aug 18, 2001
    Messages:
    2,213
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Student
    Location:
    Baltimore, MD, United States
    Home Page:
    I voted for the Children of Hurin. It's just a better read.

    The Silmarillion is "nice". The stories contained within it, while grand and epic, are still written more like a history text than as a real narrative. The versions of the stories of the Silmarillion are much more exciting reads when you peruse their more "raw" forms in the Unfinished Tales and Histories of Middle Earth.

    In all honesty, though, it's not really fair to compare the two. They're two different sorts of books. If more fleshed-out versions of Silm stories are published (such as the Akallabeth, Fall of Gondolin, Lay of Luthien, etc), then those would be things you could better compare the Children of Hurin to.
     
  12. Erinkill

    Erinkill New Member

    Joined:
    May 6, 2010
    Messages:
    1
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Most importantly, which one of them should I read first?
     
  13. Ciryaher

    Ciryaher Witch of Resurrection

    Joined:
    Aug 18, 2001
    Messages:
    2,213
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Student
    Location:
    Baltimore, MD, United States
    Home Page:
    If you want a specific, well-done story, read the Children of Hurin first. If you want a general overview of Middle Earth's history leading up to the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit books, read The Silmarillion.

    :)
     
  14. adpirtle

    adpirtle Registered User

    Joined:
    Feb 8, 2011
    Messages:
    28
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    0
    You have to read the Silmarillion first. Otherwise you won't be able to appreciate half of what's going on.

    As for which one's better, well I loved the Silmarillion. Some people have said its structure, being a collection of legends written in archaic (in the literary sense) fashion and weaved together to make a sort of 'Elf bible', doesn't lend itself to light reading. However, I just loved it. The audiobook is really well done too (though a few names are mispronounced by the talented narrator).

    Children of Hurin is similarly archaic in its prose, but there is more of a narrative since its covering the life of one young man rather than the span of many centuries. Its an easier read, and for my money its also the greatest story in the Silmarillion which only benefits from being fleshed out. But like I said, there's so much you won't really appreciate unless you read the other book first. Or you can read them together (just replace chapter 21 with Children of Hurin!
     
  15. MAVONDURI

    MAVONDURI Registered User

    Joined:
    Jan 30, 2011
    Messages:
    9
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Home Page:
    Honestly I can't say which one is better. The Silmarillion is very "historical" in its style and structure, and you're able to delve into the reading. COH on the other hand is a beautifully written tragic tale, and always a good read. So I can't definitively say which one is better, even if it's just my opinion.
     
  16. Sulimo

    Sulimo Registered User

    Joined:
    Apr 23, 2011
    Messages:
    244
    Likes Received:
    11
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    geologist
    Location:
    Houston
    I refuse to vote. Its too much like comparing apples to apple seeds. I appreciate them both, and loved them both. I think what may be a more appropriate comparison might be Children of Hurin to the Narn I Hin Hurin in the Unfinished Tales. Then Children of Hurin wins hands down.
     
  17. Bard the Bowman

    Bard the Bowman Archer of Dale

    Joined:
    May 23, 2011
    Messages:
    424
    Likes Received:
    3
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    Lord of the Rings Specialist
    Location:
    Esgaroth
    It's not a fair vote. They can't be directly compared. Us true Tolkien fanatics will see this. Children of Hurin is fantastic. You get up close and personal to one of the most torn characters in the whole Middle-Earth/Beleriand/Valinor world. The Silmarillion is awesome because you get the history of everything that happened. I WILL NOT VOTE!!!
     
  18. Ithilethiel

    Ithilethiel Active Member

    Joined:
    May 6, 2018
    Messages:
    166
    Likes Received:
    153
    Trophy Points:
    43
    Gender:
    Female
    Location:
    Woodland Realm
    The Silmarillion by a good margin. So much to delve into, tales of every kind and for every like and interest. Peerless writing and as a history freak it is very satisfying.

    I must say as a Tolkien fan I also enjoy the CoH for its cohesion and beauty but it is rather bleak and obtuse at times. Without the backstory of The Silmarillion it also lacks some important underpinnings for me. Perhaps the CoH is too, "adult" for me.

    At any rate, it's The Silmarillion I return to again and again for its history, beauty and imagination.
     
  19. BountyHunter

    BountyHunter Member

    Joined:
    Nov 5, 2018
    Messages:
    38
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    8
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Kenora, Ontario, Canada
    I just started Children of Hurin. I'm finding it a LOT easier to understand than I did The Silmarillion. Of course, I haven't read the latter since I was around 17, so that may have something to do with it.

    Silmarillion is winging its way to me in the mail as we speak, so I'll be giving it another chance then.