🧙 The Tolkien Forum 🧝

Welcome to our forum! Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox! Plus you won't see ads ;)

Search results

  1. Confusticated

    The Official 2011 Birthday Thread

    HLG, you can't be 26... but... but you were just 18? I remember it! Grond was here, and Rangerdave, maybe even ReadWryt. Enjoy your remaining 20s... and beyond...
  2. Confusticated

    "West" of the Great Road = Amon Din??

    The Great Road = "West" of Amon Din?? On which road was the enemy encamped? Amon Din is East of the Great Road. Though maybe several miles west of where the Rohirrim were bivouacked at the foot of Eilenach Beacon.
  3. Confusticated

    The Feanor Craftsmen?

    Gandalf says he wants to look in the Palanatir and see Feanor at work. What are Feanor? Are they the ones Legolas heard whispering in the rock? Was Narvi a Feano or were they strictly elves? Were they only in the past?
  4. Confusticated


    What did Galdor Ingloin mean by exiles? From where? Undying Lands? Why? Is Inglorion related to Ingwe since family members have similar names in Middle-earth?
  5. Confusticated

    Dwarvish Elves

    How dwarfy and elfy are elves and dwarves. (When Eru gave Dwarves will did they rebell against Aule? Would they have had he tried to remain in control of them like he original was. Come to it, are Eru and Melkor just fighting against eachother both over control of us and using our will as...
  6. Confusticated

    ABCs of Photo Album

    Some of these that are links to other sites or threads may not still be valid. The only invalid ones omitted are a few I happened to look at out of curiosity and noticed were gone. The names gives are the names of those in the photos, except where the photo does not contain a forum member, in...
  7. Confusticated


    Could they be normal men? If you stop and think maybe it was some secret organization where once an old man dies a new old man takes his palce? Maybe Hobbit Gandalf and LOTR Gandalf are not the same dude. This could tell why he was slow to understand what Bilbo had found? It will also tell...
  8. Confusticated

    Saeros high in the ranks of things...

  9. Confusticated

    A variety of origins for orcs....

    I don't especially believe they are beasts in origin, but I think it is possible. The only option I disagree with is that orcs are automations.
  10. Confusticated

    To hell with Eldar!

  11. Confusticated

    "There they lie still and await us..."

  12. Confusticated

    Sindarin among Noldor during WotJ.

  13. Confusticated

    Dagor Bragollach & sons of Feanor

  14. Confusticated

    Frodo's final weakness.