🧙 The Tolkien Forum 🧝

Welcome to our forum! Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox! Plus you won't see ads ;)

M-e 21 questions (or "Who or what am I")

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
 

Olorgando

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2019
Messages
576
Reaction score
266
Location
Germany
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)?
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)? No, and if your thinking of Sting then also no.
 

Olorgando

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2019
Messages
576
Reaction score
266
Location
Germany
12. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain "wizard" who changed colors?
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)? No, and if your thinking of Sting then also no.
12. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain "wizard" who changed colors?
CA1D4D01-7A12-42EE-9E31-E4FDF66F512B.jpeg
No
418578C7-813E-41C6-85EC-95E0A5DFC225.jpeg
And no!
 

Olorgando

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2019
Messages
576
Reaction score
266
Location
Germany
13. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain scruffy-looking northern ranger whom Barliman Butterbur thought not to be the best company for four Hobbits to keep?
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)? No, and if your thinking of Sting then also no.
12. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain "wizard" who changed colors? No and no.
13. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain scruffy-looking northern ranger whom Barliman Butterbur thought not to be the best company for four Hobbits to keep? Not really.
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)? No, and if your thinking of Sting then also no.
12. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain "wizard" who changed colors? No and no.
13. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain scruffy-looking northern ranger whom Barliman Butterbur thought not to be the best company for four Hobbits to keep? Not really.
14. Did you have two different names during you existence? In my current state, no.
15. Were you carried by a man? Yes.
 

Olorgando

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2019
Messages
576
Reaction score
266
Location
Germany
@ ArwenStar: a guess (of maximum three) does not count as a question towards the limit of 21 of those; so we now have 15 questions and 1 guess ...
Guess 1: Are you Andúril 'Flame of the West', the Sword of Aragorn?
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)? No, and if your thinking of Sting then also no.
12. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain "wizard" who changed colors? No and no.
13. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain scruffy-looking northern ranger whom Barliman Butterbur thought not to be the best company for four Hobbits to keep? Not really.
14. Did you have two different names during you existence? In my current state, no.
15. Were you carried by a man? Yes.
Guess 1: Are you Andúril 'Flame of the West', the Sword of Aragorn? Not really.
 

Olorgando

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2019
Messages
576
Reaction score
266
Location
Germany
(not really? 🤨)
Guess 2: Are you Narsil 'Red-and-White-Flame', the Sword of Elendil, later to be re-forged as Andúril?
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)? No, and if your thinking of Sting then also no.
12. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain "wizard" who changed colors? No and no.
13. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain scruffy-looking northern ranger whom Barliman Butterbur thought not to be the best company for four Hobbits to keep? Not really.
14. Did you have two different names during you existence? In my current state, no.
15. Were you carried by a man? Yes.
Guess 1: Are you Andúril 'Flame of the West', the Sword of Aragorn? Not really.
Guess 2: Are you Narsil 'Red-and-White-Flame', the Sword of Elendil, later to be re-forged as Andúril? You are so close to being right and in a way you are but I was thinking of something with a bit more words... (is this a hint?)
 

ArwenStar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
199
Reaction score
52
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
1. Are you portable? Yes.
2. Are you a manufactured object? Yes.
3. Would you normally be seen with an elf? At the very first, yes, to start with, no, later, yes, at the very end, no.
4. Are you a piece of jewelry? Certainly not!
5. Are you a weapon? Yes.
6. Were you manufactured in First Age? Yes I was.
7. Are you Gurthang? No.
8. Do you play a part in later ages, like perhaps in the Third Age? Yes I do.
9. Do you belong to the sword / knife family of weapons? Yes.
10. Were you carried by a dwarf? No way!
11. Are your owners in the Third Age two consecutive Hobbits (and, for a short time, a third)? No, and if your thinking of Sting then also no.
12. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain "wizard" who changed colors? No and no.
13. Was your owner in the Third Age a certain scruffy-looking northern ranger whom Barliman Butterbur thought not to be the best company for four Hobbits to keep? Not really.
14. Did you have two different names during you existence? In my current state, no.
15. Were you carried by a man? Yes.
Guess 1: Are you Andúril 'Flame of the West', the Sword of Aragorn? Not really.
Guess 2: Are you Narsil 'Red-and-White-Flame', the Sword of Elendil, later to be re-forged as Andúril? You are so close to being right and in a way you are but I was thinking of something with a bit more words... (is this a hint?)
Guess 3: Is it the Sword that was Broken? Yes finally!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🙂 :):) 🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂 :):):)

Your go, Starbrow!
 

Olorgando

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2019
Messages
576
Reaction score
266
Location
Germany
Nag, nag: forgot the dashes! "the Sword-that-was-broken".
nag, nag, nagnagnagnag ...
😜
 

Thread suggestions

Top