I was wondering what the members of this fine guild made of the Trilogy. I myself, enjoyed the movies immensely, despite being disappointed in moderation at sections jumbled and omitted, but as films I enjoyed them greatly for what they were. Albeit, I got odd looks from my friends, as well as the audiance around me when I explained various aspects of character traits that the film had ommitted. The 2nd time I went to see it, I got into a half hour dicussion (mainly a monologue) with a friend who asked what made elves immortal. I'm not entirely sure that I answered his question, but I did blurt a good deal of Ainulindale and Valaquenta at him, after which he just said 'Ah.'. So, where does the Guild stand on the films.