It's no contest. Feanor did a great thing in creating the Silmarils. Then he proceeded to shake the foundations of Aman by inciting the rebellion that ended up killing thousands of his kinsman at Aqualonde. Next, he abandons his half brother Fingolfin, with many of his brethren and forces them to march into the extreme North where who knows how many perish due to hardship. He then wages war on any and all who even speak of attempting to retake the Silmarils. He then dies without ever even getting Morgoth into combat. What a pompous jerk and a thoroughly despicable Elf.Originally posted by Curufinwe
You have got to be kidding me, you prefer Fingolfin over Feanor?
Welcome to the forum Bombur.